Riddle Contest Day 6: Bahari Bay!

Hey Jammers! Welcome to Day 6 of the Riddle Contest. ^_^

Before we begin, I just want to say thank-you to Arcticstar Jamaa for the compliment on my short story! Because it was in a contest entry, I can't publish it yet, so I just wanted to thank them here. :)

If you're new, here's what this Riddle Contest is all about: Every day of the contest will focus on one land in Jamaa. There will be a riddle about one animal from that land's Journey Book, and it will be your job to guess which one it is!

Whoever answers the most riddles correctly will win a FREE CUSTOM MASTERPIECE! 

It would be in your best interest to answer every riddle to give you a better chance. Even if you haven't answered the previous riddles yet, you can answer them any time up until the end of the contest on April 22nd.

- Link to Riddle #1

- Link to Riddle #2
- Link to Riddle #3
- Link to Riddle #4
- Link to Riddle #5

Today, we'll dive down deeper into the blue Bahari Bay...

(If you want to skip the short story and get straight to the riddle, it's at the bottom in big bold letters.)

You enter Bahari Bay through a small underwater tunnel. As you paddle through the reeds, you become aware of your need to breathe. You swim upwards and break through the water's surface with a deep gasp of air. Gripping onto the weathered wooden ladder, you look up at the blue sky over Crystal Sands before taking a deep breath and plunging back beneath the waves once more.

You notice that Bahari Bay seems to have a slightly lower depth than Crystal Reef, so the creatures who populate the area are quite different. Where Crystal Reef had a lively and visible community of coral, Bahari Bay has an almost endless forest of seaweed, waving gently with the tide. Although it obscures your view of the darker water, you see many flickers of fins and tails from between the reeds. This underwater forest seems to provide protection to a diverse city of fish by concealing them from view!

Your gaze travels up the cliffs of blue-black rock inhabited by the more visible citizens of the Bay, from the ancient, earth-toned barrel sponges to the families of happy clams who periodically part their shells to feast on passing plankton.

As you're looking up, you catch sight of something strange on the bottom of the floating wooden dock. You swim upwards in its direction-- careful not to bump your head on the dock, of course.

The strange thing you saw turns out not to be a group of intricately clustered barnacles, as you had previously thought, but a written inscription!

You read through it carefully, once and then twice. Written in messy handwriting, it seems to be some kind of riddle!

It reads:

"'This riddle is crazy,' you might say,

but I'm dying to know,

which creature is the ice cream of the Bay?"

HINT: Look in your Journey Book!

This riddle is admittedly a little harder than the others, but I know that you have the power to solve it! :D

*Comment your AJ username, your answer to the riddle, and what you would like me to draw for you in a Masterpiece if you win!*

Again, if you have already told me your Masterpiece request in a previous comment, you do not have to repeat yourself again. 

Get ready for tomorrow, when we will continue our underwater expeditions into DEEP BLUE!

I believe in youuuu!!!

~DoomyPanda